Welcome to Maya's Pizzeria Restaurant
Maya's Pizzeria Restaurant, located at 518 Hamilton St, Somerset, NJ, offers a unique fusion of Italian and Mexican cuisines. Renowned for its delicious grandma pizza and flavorful tacos, the restaurant is a beloved local gem. The warm hospitality of the owners creates a welcoming atmosphere despite some seating constraints. Diners have praised the freshness of ingredients, particularly the vibrant basil in their Margherita pizza and the savory sausage in the Chef Miguel pie. While the dine-in area may benefit from enhancement, the eager service and mouthwatering dishes make Maya’s a must-visit destination for food lovers seeking delightful flavors.
-
518 Hamilton St, Somerset, NJ 08873, United States Hotline: +1 732-253-5399
Welcome to Maya's Pizzeria Restaurant, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Somerset, NJ. Located at 518 Hamilton St, this eatery beautifully intertwines the rich flavors of Italian cuisine with vibrant Mexican dishes. As you step inside, you’re greeted by the warmth of friendly service, embodying the spirit of community that Maya's aims to foster.
Patrons rave about the menu, which is an eclectic blend that goes beyond just pizza. From their mouthwatering grandma pizza—a standout favorite that has won the hearts of many, to a delightful mix of tacos featuring beef and chorizo, each dish is prepared with high-quality ingredients that reflect the careful craftsmanship behind each recipe.
Many customers have praised the owners for their genuine hospitality. One diner, Roosevelt, noted the owner's friendly demeanor during their visit, enjoying both the tacos and the famous grandma pizza. The warmth and dedication from the staff seem to enhance the dining experience, making it feel more personal and inviting.
Although the dine-in area could benefit from a touch of tidiness, visitors have acknowledged that the culinary experience more than makes up for it. Paris Keller and Megan Justice shared that even in a casual setting, the food shines bright. They appreciated the ample portions and freshness of ingredients—particularly noting the delicious basil on the Margarita pizza and the savory sausage on Chef Miguel’s special.
Sadly, the community mourns the loss of Chef Miguel, whose legacy continues through the delicious offerings at Maya's. As many customers have expressed their condolences, it is heartening to see his vision carried on by his family, ensuring that every visit remains special and soul-satisfying.
Moreover, don’t miss out on the unique beverages! Kevin Domenech highly recommends their refreshing cucumber lemonade—a perfect complement to the hearty meals.
In summary, whether you're craving a classic pizza, exploring some tantalizing Mexican options, or simply in the mood for a cozy meal surrounded by welcoming faces, Maya's Pizzeria Restaurant is your destination. With every dish, you can taste the love and care that defines this local favorite, making it easy to see why so many return week after week. Make sure to stop by or give them a call at +1 732-253-5399 to experience it for yourself.
Met with the owner last super friendly guy, ordered the tacos beef and chorizo and a grandma pizza pie. Pros and cons the seating is a little a tight but I dint care about how a place looks as long as the food is good. the tacos were decent I would of likes some pico on mine but decent overall. the grandma pie stood out for us we loved the pizza and the owner for that we will definitely come back. thanks again.
My mom and I are in town visiting family and staying nearby. I wasn't paying full attention when looking at this place on here, so was surprised to see the complete assortment of the menu when we got there (just thought it was Italian food). This was not a bad thing, though! Everything on the menu looked good! When we walked up I didn't think we could dine in. The signs on the door said "take out or delivery" and the tables inside were a bit in a disarray. However, as soon as we mentioned we would want to dine in, the young girl working straightened up the area quickly for us to sit. We ordered a large (18") pizza. Half Chef Miguel and half Margarita. Pizza came out hot and fresh. Slices were large (4 of each - 8 total). You could tell the basil was fresh on the Margarita side and the sausage on the Chef Miguel side was so good. Overall we loved it. The food was delicious and the service was fantastic! Only reason I didn't give 5 stars is because I felt like the dine in area could have been a bit more presentable or welcoming (but it wasn't terrible). Also, sad to read in the reviews that Chef Miguel passed away recently. May he rest easy and in peace.
Owners are wonderful. Always friendly personal service. Happy with the chicken or Rib dinner combos among many other items on the menu. Food is delicious. We order from here at least once a week. Update: We were so sad to hear of Miguel's passing in April. May he Rest in Heaven. Our sincere condolences to his family and friends. His son and co-owner do a great job preserving his legacy, Food is always great.
Was in the area so I did somr Pizza Scouting for the Pizza Hunters App. The Parking is difficult so you may have to use the side streets. The Pizza was your standard slice of Pizza. Not Great, Not Bad. Basic ingredients that will fill your belly. Was not feeling the barriers between service and the customer. The presentation of the Slices was below average as well. I am sure it's a good spot for the locals, but I would not go out of my way.
Ordered 2 pizzas from here based on others photos. Plain was good and 2nd had lots of fresh toppings. Will try some other menu items soon.
Amazing pizza and Mexican dishes, high quality ingredients with a great staff, definitely recommend getting their cucumber lemonade, very refreshing and delicious. Will definitely be returning.
The tamles were amazing verdes spicy and well filled of chicken. The pork red wasn’t spicy but as well. The huarache was good. The tacos was good but had la tortilla was fry. The space is peaceful to just come in a relax with some of your food. La horchata and la jamaica are amazing.
Our first time and we were in love! If you are all-in persona, go for the chef miguel one. Good prices and excellent service